Mathematical Food for Thought

 
 
google
yahoo
bing
 
  • About

    Serves a Daily Special and an All-You-Can-Eat Course in Problem Solving. Courtesy of me, Jeffrey Wang.
 
RSI 2006 March 31st, 2006

For anyone interested, I got accepted and will be attending!

Zero Has No Friends. Topic: Combinatorics/Inequalities/Sets. Level: Olympiad. March 30th, 2006

Problem: (360 Problems For Mathematical Contests – 6.1.9) Find the maximum number of nonzero terms of the sum

 \displaystyle \sum_{i,j=1}^n |f(i)-f(j)|

where  f:\{1,2,\ldots,n\} \rightarrow \{a,b,c\} is one of the  3^n possible functions.

Solution: Let  x be the number of elements  p \in \{1,2,\ldots,n\} such that  f(p) = a . Similarly define  y and  z to be the corresponding values for  f(p) = b and  f(p) = c , respectively. Since there are  n total values in the domain, we know  x+y+z = n .

We will try counting the opposite of what we want and minimizing it; the number of pairs such that  |f(i)-f(j)| = 0 . The number of ways we can pick two elements that map to  a is  x^2 ( x choices for both the first and second). Similarly, the number that map to  b and  c are  y^2 and  z^2 , respectively.

Now it remains to minimize  x^2+y^2+z^2 for  x+y+z = n . By Cauchy or AM-GM, we know  x^2+y^2+z^2 \ge \frac{1}{3}(x+y+z)^2 = \frac{n^2}{3} . But remember that  x,y,z have to be positive integers, so we have two separate cases: (1) if  n is a multiple of  3 , then the minimum is  \frac{n^2}{3} , (2) otherwise, it is  \frac{n^2+2}{3} .

So we then subtract the minimum number of zero terms from the total number of terms  n^2 to get  \frac{2n^2}{3} if  n is a multiple of  3 and  \frac{2(n^2-1)}{3} otherwise. This can also be stated as  \left\lfloor \frac{2n^2}{3} \right\rfloor . QED.

——————–

Comment: It can be a good idea to look at the complement of what you actually are counting because it may be a lot simpler to count. This is a common technique in probability problems as well.

——————–

Practice Problem: (360 Problems For Mathematical Contests – 6.1.6) Let  a_1, a_2, \ldots, a_n be positive real numbers and let  k \ge 0 . Prove that

 \displaystyle k+\sqrt[n]{\prod_{i=1}^n a_i} \le \sqrt[n]{\prod_{i=1}^n (k+a_i)} \le k +\frac{1}{n} \sum_{i=1}^n a_i .

Set To Set. Topic: Sets. Level: Olympiad. March 29th, 2006

Problem: (360 Problems For Mathematical Contests – 6.1.4) Let  A be a set with  n elements and let  X be a subset of  A with  k \ge 1 elements. Find the number of functions  f: A \rightarrow A such that  f(X) = X .

Problem: First consider the elements of  X . Since  f(X) has to return the same set of elements, no two elements  a,b \in X can have  f(a) = f(b) (or we wouldn’t be able to get the entire set back). So if we pick any element  a we have  k choices for  f(a) . Then when we pick  b we only have  k-1 choices for  f(b) . Continuing this, we find that there are  k! ways to assign each element in  X .

Now for the other  n-k elements of  A , we can arbitrarily assign where they map to. Since each has  n elements to map to, there is an additional factor of  n^{n-k} to the number of functions.

This gives us a total of  k! \cdot n^{n-k} possible functions  f . QED.

——————–

Comment: Basic sets and functions are a good thing to know in order to build on. They don’t require much mathematical background to work through, and are mostly logical (with some combinatorics).

——————–

Practice Problem: (360 Problems For Mathematical Contests – 6.1.1) Let  A be a set with  n elements and let  B be a subset of  A with  m \ge 1 elements. Find the number of functions  f: A \rightarrow A such that  f(B) \subseteq B .

Ceva’s Here! Topic: Geometry/Inequalities. Level: Olympiad. March 28th, 2006

Problem: (1996 IMO Shortlist – #13) Let  ABC be an equilateral triangle and let  P be a point in its interior. Let the lines  AP, BP, CP meet the sides  BC, CA, AB at the points  A_1, B_1, C_1 , respectively. Prove that

 A_1B_1 \cdot B_1C_1 \cdot C_1A_1 \ge A_1B \cdot B_1C \cdot C_1A .

1996IMOShortlist-13

Solution: First thing to take into account is the fact that the triangle is equilateral. There is probably a good reason for this, so let’s try and find it. Applying the Law of Cosines on triangle  A_1B_1C , we find

 (A_1B_1)^2 = (A_1C)^2+(B_1C)^2-A_1C \cdot B_1C .

But since  (A_1C-B_1C)^2 \ge 0 \Rightarrow (A_1C)^2+(B_1C)^2-A_1C \cdot B_1C \ge A_1C \cdot B_1C , we have

 (A_1B_1)^2 \ge A_1C \cdot B_1C .

Similarly,  (B_1C_1)^2 \ge B_1A \cdot C_1A and  (C_1A_1)^2 \ge C_1B \cdot A_1B . Multiplying these three inequalities together, we obtain

 (A_1B_1 \cdot B_1C_1 \cdot C_1A_1)^2 \ge (A_1B \cdot B_1C \cdot C_1A)(A_1C \cdot B_1A \cdot C_1B) .

But by Ceva’s, we know  A_1B \cdot B_1C \cdot C_1A = A_1C \cdot B_1A \cdot C_1B , so

 (A_1B_1 \cdot B_1C_1 \cdot C_1A_1)^2 \ge (A_1B \cdot B_1C \cdot C_1A)^2

and

 A_1B_1 \cdot B_1C_1 \cdot C_1A_1 \ge A_1B \cdot B_1C \cdot C_1A

as desired. QED.

——————–

Comment: After we were able to figure out an effective way to use the equilateral condition, it wasn’t hard to see the inequality there. Then the problem just asks for Ceva, which fits in nicely at the end.

——————–

Practice Problem: (1996 USAMO – #5) Let ABC be a triangle, and M an interior point such that \angle MAB=10^\circ, \angle MBA=20^\circ, \angle MAC=40^\circ, and \angle MCA=30^\circ. Prove that the triangle is isosceles.

Yum! Topic: Inequalities. Level: Olympiad. March 27th, 2006

Problem: Let  a,b,c be positive reals such that  a^2+b^2+c^2 = 3 . Prove that

 \frac{a}{a^3+a^2+4}+\frac{b}{b^3+b^2+4}+\frac{c}{c^3+c^2+4} \le \frac{1}{2} .

Solution: We will use a method of solving inequalities called “Isolated Fudging.” Since the variables are separated we will prove an inequality for each individual term. We guess that there exists a real  k such that

 \frac{a}{a^3+a^2+4} \le \frac{1}{6}+ka^2-k .

Doing the same for each variable and summing up, we see that this will prove the result. To find  k , we throw in some calculus (the part ensuing is not necessary in a formal solution write-up, so you don’t need to include any calculus in the “official” solution).

Let  f(a) = \frac{1}{6}+ka^2-k-\frac{a}{a^3+a^2+4} . Differentiating with respect to  a , we have

 f^{\prime}(a) = 2ak-\frac{(a^3+a^2+4)-a(3a^2+2a)}{(a^3+a^2+4)^2} .

Looking at the equality case in the problem, we see that  a = b = c = 1 . So if our guess is correct, then  f^{\prime}(1) = 0 . So

 f^{\prime}(1) = 2k-\frac{1}{36} = 0 \Rightarrow k = \frac{1}{72} .

Now back to the solution. It remains to show that

 \frac{a}{a^3+a^2+4} \le \frac{1}{6}+\frac{1}{72}a^2-\frac{1}{72} = \frac{11}{72}+\frac{1}{72}a^2 ,

which is equivalent to

 72a \le (a^3+a^2+4)(a^2+11) ,

or

 0 \le (a-1)^2(a^3+3a^2+16a+44) .

Since  a is a positive real, we have  a^3+3a^2+16a+44 > 0 and  (a-1)^2 \ge 0 , so it is true. Hence

 \frac{a}{a^3+a^2+4}+\frac{b}{b^3+b^2+4}+\frac{c}{c^3+c^2+4} \le \left(\frac{11}{72}+\frac{1}{72}a^2\right) + \left(\frac{11}{72}+\frac{1}{72}b^2\right) + \left(\frac{11}{72}+\frac{1}{72}c^2\right) = \frac{1}{2} ,

as desired. QED.

——————–

Comment: Isolated Fudging is a pretty neat trick and there are many variations on it, which are nice to learn. It lets you come up with solutions that have extremely strange numbers but magically work out.

——————–

Practice Problem: (2005 IMO – #3) Prove that for all positive  a,b,c with product at least  1 ,

  \frac{a^5-a^2}{a^5+b^2+c^2} + \frac{b^5-b^2}{b^5+c^2+a^2} + \frac{c^5-c^2}{c^5+a^2+b^2} \ge 0 .

Google

 

 
 
free web counters
Etronics